Us and them? [was Re: Livecode Dictionary]

Curry Kenworthy curry at
Mon Jan 21 19:25:51 EST 2019


 > a conflict between the “everyone can code” philosophy [...]
 > and the perceived need to be more professional and serious as a
 > player in the whole software development arena.


Nor should it be assumed that pros and trend-chasers are always 
serious/correct and others are not - I've seen some sloppy "pros" and 
some excellent beginners. People at all levels of software or LC can do 
a great job. (Or not.)

Likewise the trap of assuming that following new trends always brings 
better results. Imagine a Venn diagram between software innovations, 
trends, and another important factor such as quality or efficiency. 
Sometimes or some situations they go together, sometimes not.

 > but it’s not OK if this is at the expense of the kind of user
 > who doesn’t want to distort the way LC works, for example by
 > deprecating stacks that contain both scripts and UI elements

I wasn't aware of a plan or push to deprecate those - I don't follow all 
threads, but I emphatically hope not; bad idea! I want LC stacks to 
remain stacks. Easy to use and learn, self-contained, smart.

Git is also smart, very useful for many situations, but not superior in 
all situations. There are trade-offs, just as there are with agile dev. 
Savvy people are aware of pros and cons. Trend-chasers: maybe not aware. 
Good to have both options.

(If this is referencing my own remarks about mixing data and UI for 
files saved at compiled runtime, that's a completely different matter.)

 > cancelling of the ability of these ordinary users to add notes
 > to the dictionary

Yep, it's worthwhile to keep LC 6 handy for those notes! Highly 
valuable. Continuing user comments for LC 9+ would be a smart move.


 > worrying about Microsoft, if one spends too much time on it can
 > become fairly unhealthy: and what about Apple, Canonical, and
 > so on and so forth?

Tribal identity marketing; be careful for people coming after you with 
OS logos and pitchforks, but I totally agree. Tribalism mindset works 
pretty well for group survival, but fails at most other things including 
accurate assessments. Fun social experiment: "MS and Apple are not 
nearly as different as their fans like to think." :D

 > the Dictionary inwith LiveCode to regain its previous functionality
 > so we can help each other just that wee bit more.

Yep, that would be helpful.

Best wishes,

Curry Kenworthy

Custom Software Development
"Better Methods, Better Results"
LiveCode Training and Consulting

More information about the Use-livecode mailing list