RR Forums

David Bovill david at openpartnership.net
Wed Sep 6 00:38:50 EDT 2006


Prediction: the RunRev Forum will not be used.

The list will continue to be used. The wiki will not be used. The list
will be continued to be used. Neither the Forum or the Wiki offer
anything compelling over the list. They could have but they do not.

The forum is half way between a wiki and the list. The list is
integrated with neither. The Rev IDE is integrated with neither. The
Forum will dilute the wiki, and the wiki will dilute the Forum. Users
will not know where to look for what. The Forum is not integrated with
the Wiki. Functionally the whole thing is a mess with all the parts
counteracting each other.

Still in time - things will get around to being sorted. Either the
Forum or the wiki will be dropped. Most likely the wiki - for the
wrong reasons. Possibly both - not because these things do not work -
but because they are executed badly without an understanding of
community and motivational issues.

My recommendation? Dump either the Forum or the wiki. I would
recommend dumping the Forum. Make sure that whichever one is chosen
integrates with the list. Either by changes to the wiki being posted
to the list or something better. Next work with the community to
ensure that "stuff gets published". The solution is not technical it
is social.



More information about the Use-livecode mailing list