Laptop diary tool in REV - Glyphs

[Mark Smith]

And on a related note, and also not to denigrate anyones work, but  
one thing that still drives me round the bend is a row of icons  
without captions.
Icons on their own, imho, are useful as visual aides-memoires to  
where something is once you already know what you're looking for, but  
simply confusing when you are unfamiliar with a particular app.

One example is a truly horrible audio editing program I had to use  
once or twice, which had about 30 buttons with captionless icons in a  
column down one side of the window, if I remember correctly.  One of  
these buttons was for joining two sections of audio into one, and  
another for separating a section of audio into two.

I still can't remember which was which, but one had a picture of a  
closed zip fastener with the zipper at the top, the other a picture  
of an open zip fastener with the zipper at the bottom. I had to  
either hover the mouse over one of them and wait for the tool-tip to  
appear, or just click one and undo if it turned out to be wrong. The  
simple inclusion of the captions "join" and "separate" would have  
saved me endless frustration and annoyance.

They were nasty, crude icons, too. :)

Tool-tips just don't cut it at all, as far as I'm concerned, though  
they can be useful for slightly more explanation than a caption,  
where necessary.

Now I'm as keen on the GUI as anyone else, but it seems to me that  
this avoidance of text at all costs is all part of a general dumbing  
down, along with the use (previously discussed on this list) of the  
infantile "my" prefix for almost everything, like we're all tiny  
children playing with my little pony. Perhaps it's supposed to soften  
the terrifying intellectual strain of having to read words like  
'computer', 'documents' etc.

Bit of a rant, I know, but I feel better already .... thanks for  
listening :)

Mark

ps. You were lucky, I did all my work etching letters into basalt  
with my finger nails....

On 17 Jun 2006, at 16:02, Richmond Mathewson wrote:

> Aah!
>
> 1 thing worries me about Phenomenalog (and it is not Phenomenalog  
> specific):
>
> When I began programming computers most people wrote things by  
> hand; when I went to University people laughed at me because I did  
> my academic work on a typewriter (1982). No people do all sorts of  
> things using computers where they never even have to encounter text.
>
> Subsequently, the wierdos who use typewriters are not wierdos  
> because they are ahead of their time!
>
> Now (and I referred to the Symbol World website {http:// 
> www.symbolworld.org/}) I see a move away from a literate populace  
> to one that communicates with Glyphs/Icons/Pictographs - and I find  
> this a bit worrying as it seems to be a step backwards - leading to  
> a paucity of expression (see section in Gulliver's Travels).
>
> Now I understand diaries to consist largely of subtle thoughts (or,  
> at least have the potential to contain them and all their  
> concommitant nuances of meaning) which cannot be adequately  
> communicated in pictorial symbols.
>
> This statement is not to be taken as a denigration of Bjerg's work  
> at all - it should empower a very large proportion of humanity who  
> have previously been disenfranchised by the computer revolution.
>
> sincerely, Richmond Mathewson
>
>
> ____________________________________________________________
>
> "Philosophical problems are confusions arising owing to the  
> fluidity of meanings users attach to words and phrases."
>                                        Mathewson, 2006
> ____________________________________________________________
>  		
> ---------------------------------
>  Now you can scan emails quickly with a reading pane. Get the new  
> Yahoo! Mail.
> _______________________________________________
> use-revolution mailing list
> use-revolution at lists.runrev.com
> Please visit this url to subscribe, unsubscribe and manage your  
> subscription preferences:
> http://lists.runrev.com/mailman/listinfo/use-revolution