"Aphasia" (was Re: use-livecode Digest, Vol 171, Issue 44)
richmondmathewson at gmail.com
Thu Dec 28 06:24:00 EST 2017
Indeed, it is more complicated as we all, to one extent or another,
suffer from a "pathology of semantics or word finding"
as, this morning, I couldn't for the life of me remember what part of
the brain was supposedly connected with aphasia
and had to go and look the thing up.
I do not adhere to a Brain-Mind Identity theory, so tend to think that
any sort of mental problem involves more than
just the physical state of the "cauliflower" inside our heads.
I don't know about neuropsychologists, but I would suggest going to meet
"Granny" and having a chat with her to get
a feel for what might be the symptoms (after all, who really cares WHY
and whether its the brain, the mind (ouch - J.J.C.Smart),
or something else) and how they can, possibly, be alleviated.
We've dragged my Mother-in-law to various "quacks" who have offered
various accounts of what is going on, with varying
degrees of plausability: she has played around with various course of
tablets to little or no effect beyond making various
drug companies richer. Probably the answer is something like "She's not
a teenager any more."
I have just had a most entertaining chat with her about why we have 2
cleaning ladies who look identical, but one is good
and one is evil. There really didn't seem any point in explaining that
our cleaning lady is human, and like all humans, has
bad moods as well as good moods, and is not the best person in the world
at covering her bad moods up: mainly because
I've explained that twice before and it just hasn't "gelled". Doesn't
stop my Mother-in-law from making very sharp, pertinent
remarks in other subject areas. What is rather "fun" is how she keeps
injecting Albanian words into conversations nowadays,
not because she speaks Albanian but because her grandparents on one side
used to speak it at home: really serves to confuse
us, and I sometimes have a sneaking suspicion my ma-in-law is actually
pulling our legs.
On 28/12/17 11:04 am, David Glasgow via use-livecode wrote:
> Unfortunately, it is all rather more complicated than either Richmond or Peter suggest. There are many more contributing areas than Brocas, and what Peter describes doesn't appear to be aphasia at all, but rather a pathology of semantics or word finding.
> It's not possible to be more specific without more information, and my advice would be to speak with a neuropsychologist before coding. You could spend a lot of time comparing wavs and coming up with a solution to the wrong problem.
> Best wishes
> David Glasgow
> Sent from my iBrain via iFingers & iPad
>> On 28 Dec 2017, at 08:26, Richmond Mathewson via use-livecode <use-livecode at lists.runrev.com> wrote:
>> If we start to unpack your post we can come to a slightly simpler conclusion than what you set out as your goal initially.
>> 1. Is your main idea to have a program where the device can "do the talking" for the patient?
>> 2. As the "owner" of a 94 year old Mother-in-law who suffers from some sort of selective dementia I realise that
>> pointing out to her that her hallucinations are hallucinations (rather than reality) is both an uphill struggle
>> and causes her a lot of distress: oddly enough she's far happier inside the comfort zone of her hallucinations.
>> If "Granny" suffers from Aphasia she has permanent damage in the Broca's Area of her brain, normally due to
>> a stroke: this cannot be sorted out, unfortunately.
>> She could, also, suffer from a type of dementia that has similar symptoms to aphasia.
>> Doesn't really matter which; the end result is just as bad and bl**dy awful for all concerned.
>> If you are going for #1 then there is absolutely no need for any speech-recognition stuff or comparison
>> between recorded sounds and those on the device.
>>> On 28/12/17 2:26 am, Peter Reid via use-livecode wrote:
>>> Hi Marc, Paul, Phil, Rick and Richmond
>>> Thanks for your various thoughts.
>>> To put a bit more flesh on this, here's what I'm developing and why...
>>> In the first instance I'm doing this development for a friend who's grandmother suffers from aphasia (saying completely the wrong word). The idea is that her family can put together sets of words where each word is spoken by the app whilst displaying a relevant picture and optionally a short video clip illustrating the correct mouth shape when saying the word. The app displays the word in a very large font with a picture, then the app says the word (with the option to see a mouth shape video clip). The user responds by trying to say the same word and (the thing I can't do yet!) the app gives the user a percentage score that represents how closely the user matched the sample word. If the user's score is above a variable threshold, the user sees a smiley face, otherwise a sad face!
>>> I tried contacting Mark Smith as suggested by Paul but his email address mark at maseurope.net no longer works.
>>> So far I have everything working apart from the comparison of 2 WAV files, in particular the following is working:
>>> - the app checks for the presence of a micro SD card as the source of a collection of word packs
>>> - a word pack consists of a collection of words in sound (WAV) and picture (JPG) form, optionally with supporting video clips (MP4)
>>> - the app lets the user select a word pack at start up and loads the pack into RW file space
>>> - the user taps a large arrow icon to go forwards/backwards through the chosen list of words
>>> - for each word, the word is displayed in a large font at the top of the landscape screen, with its associated picture occupying the lower half of the screen
>>> - as the word is displayed, it is spoken
>>> - the user can tap a microphone icon and record their attempt at the word
>>> - currently I simulate the comparison of the 2 WAV files
>>> - the app gives a percentage score and displays a smiley or sad face accordingly
>>> To be honest, my main aim is to help a friend. At this stage I'm not looking beyond this, so licensing, etc. is not on the horizon at the moment.
>>> Thanks again
>>> Peter Reid
>>> Loughborough, UK
>>> use-livecode mailing list
>>> use-livecode at lists.runrev.com
>>> Please visit this url to subscribe, unsubscribe and manage your subscription preferences:
>> use-livecode mailing list
>> use-livecode at lists.runrev.com
>> Please visit this url to subscribe, unsubscribe and manage your subscription preferences:
> use-livecode mailing list
> use-livecode at lists.runrev.com
> Please visit this url to subscribe, unsubscribe and manage your subscription preferences:
More information about the Use-livecode