Opening a Supercard file in Livecode?

[Richard Gaskin]

Bob Earp wrote:

 > Well, I think you are half correct Richard.  These sort of decisions
 > need to be made on a case by case basis....

On further consideration I think you're absolutely correct.

I was talking about this with Ken Ray last night, and we hit on a 
distinction which may be useful for deciding when to use a converter and 
when to rewrite:

If an app has more content than code use a converter, but if more code 
than content then rewrite.

Even then there may be exceptions, but the idea is that multimedia 
projects usually have a lot of objects which need to be laid out in 
specific ways, and that's the sort of thing a converter can do well; 
redoing hundreds of card layouts by hand is a waste of time.

But things like productivity apps often have relatively little content, 
i.e. fewer objects, but tons of code, and code written in another xTalk 
dialect will be of questionable value in terms of robustness, 
extensibility, and performance in LiveCode.

While xTalks have many commonalities, they're all very different 
products -- if they weren't there would be only one. :)  Those 
differences lie in object types and syntax options that result in ports 
which may have code that makes no sense in the target environment, or at 
best uses language conventions that aren't optimized for the target.

Also, many productivity apps attempt to adhere to the UI conventions of 
the host platform as much as possible, but if a project is being ported 
from an older xTalk to LiveCode chances are it was designed for an 
earlier version of the OS and needs revision to look current anyway.

Moreover, most other xTalks are single-platform tools, so they have no 
methods for handling UI differences between OSes and will require 
revision to account for that.

So code-heavy projects with relatively few objects can be an opportunity 
for updating the app not only for the current version of its original 
target platform, but for multiple platforms that it never previously had 
to take into account.

But for content-heavy apps, I fully agree:  it's nothing but RSI to 
reproduce hundreds of card layouts by hand.

--
  Richard Gaskin
  Fourth World
  LiveCode training and consulting: http://www.fourthworld.com
  Webzine for LiveCode developers: http://www.LiveCodeJournal.com
  LiveCode Journal blog: http://LiveCodejournal.com/blog.irv