Icon for OS X compiled .app not showing :-(

[Garrett Hylltun]

Rev 2.6.1

Greetings,

Ok, made .png files in sizes of 16x16, 32x32, 48x48 and 128x128.  Put 
them all in Icon Composer and saved the file as a .icns file.

Then I picked that file as the icons in the standalone settings for OS X 
and selected the dialog png files and so on.  I used the same .icns file 
for both the application and document icon.

But after the standalone was saved, the icons I made are not being used 
at all for the .app in finder.  It's using the default icon from OS X as 
if mine didn't exist or something.

Looking into the .app resouces shows both icons, and the plist file does 
name the icons appropriately.

Am I doing something wrong?

Thanks,
-Garrett