[OT] [OT - Maybe] Good/Bad Form for sample stacks

[Thomas McGrath III]

Hello all listers,

I had an experience with a sample stack that at first threw me off  
and I may have responded to the what the stack did harshly. I'm not  
sure. But it brought up a point for me.

Is it considered good form to point out how someone's hard worked  
stack performs if it does so in such an unexpected way (like the  
stack that moved my menu's did but did not put them back)? In other  
words if someone makes a stack that does something 'wrong' or 'bad'  
in my opinion, would it be considered an insult or attack OR should  
it be considered a critigue simply on the stack or code and be  
considered a positive thing?

I try to take any advise or critique as a positive thing but  
sometimes I feel slighted. I was wondering how others felt about this.

P.S. The stack in question was a good stack and showed some  
interesting things that could be done with RR but I was not ready for  
it to move my menu's and not put them back. That does not take away  
from the intent of the sample.

Yours,

Tom




Thomas J McGrath III
3mcgrath at adelphia.net

Semantic Compaction Systems
SCIconics, LLC

Lazy River Metal Arts
Lazy River Software™
&
Meeting Wear™ - Unique Apparel Design